News Summary

During the NLCS in Milwaukee, Dodgers player Teoscar Hernández decided to switch hotels after his wife expressed fears about the haunted Pfister Hotel. Despite Hernández’s skepticism about ghosts, unsettling tales from fellow players influenced their decision for alternative accommodations. The history of eerie experiences at the Pfister includes lights turning on and off, strange noises, and mysterious footsteps. Dodgers manager Dave Roberts and former players have also shared their ghostly encounters, adding to the lore surrounding this infamous hotel as the Dodgers prepare for playoff games.

Milwaukee

During the National League Championship Series (NLCS) in Milwaukee, Dodgers outfielder Teoscar Hernández opted to change hotels due to his wife’s concerns about the Pfister Hotel being haunted. Although Hernández does not believe in ghosts, his wife, Jennifer, expressed worries after hearing spooky tales from other players and their spouses. Consequently, the couple sought alternative accommodations during the crucial playoff games against the Brewers.

The Pfister Hotel, a 137-year-old establishment, is notorious among Major League Baseball (MLB) players for its haunted reputation. While Hernández has previously stayed at the hotel without experiencing any unusual occurrences, his wife’s apprehension led them to prioritize comfort over tradition. Reports from other players include eerie experiences such as lights unexpectedly turning on and off, strange noises, and even footsteps echoing in the corridors.

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts contributed to the lighthearted atmosphere surrounding the ghost stories, sharing that he lost interest in such tales by the age of ten. However, the long-standing reputation of the Pfister Hotel cannot be ignored, as even former Dodgers closer Eric Gagne described it as “old, weird and scary.” Gagne admitted to having a restless night during his stay in 2005, aligning with the sentiments expressed by other players.

Adrián Beltré, a former Dodgers player, recounted chilling experiences at the hotel from his visit in 2001, including lights turning on by themselves and the peculiar sensation of having “his toes tickled.” This anecdote, among others, has contributed to the hotel’s nickname as “baseball’s most haunted hotel.” Current players like Michael Young and Mookie Betts have also described eerie occurrences while staying at the Pfister. Betts even took the precaution of booking an Airbnb to avoid experiencing any ghostly encounters.

In the context of their current postseason success, the Dodgers managed to secure a 2-0 lead in the NLCS after winning the first two games against the Brewers. This success has alleviated any immediate concerns regarding a return to the Pfister Hotel during the postseason. As the team prepares for upcoming games at Dodger Stadium, they may choose to avoid the haunted hotel altogether, preferring to prioritize their rest and mental peace.

Beyond the stories shared by Hernández and fellow players, accounts from other MLB stars further paint a vivid picture of the eerie atmosphere at the Pfister. Bryce Harper has reported instances where his clothes mysteriously moved, while other players have claimed to experience electronics turning on without explanation. These consistent reports of eerie phenomena have solidified the Pfister Hotel’s reputation as unsettling for those involved in America’s national pastime.

As the legacy of the Pfister Hotel continues to grow, it serves as a backdrop not just for sports but also for the tales of the supernatural that accompany them. While some players express skepticism about the existence of ghosts, the tales surrounding the hotel certainly provide a uniquely entertaining narrative, linking the worlds of athletics and the paranormal in Milwaukee.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

Teoscar Hernández Avoids Haunted Hotel in Milwaukee

Additional Resources

• USA Today: Dodgers Pfister Hotel Haunted
• JSONline: MLB Players Haunted by Pfister Hotel
• People: Mookie Betts and Teoscar Hernández Avoid Haunted Hotel
• SI: Mookie Betts Refuses to Stay at Haunted Hotel
• New York Times: Dodgers and Haunted Hotel
• Wikipedia: Pfister Hotel
• Google Search: Haunted Hotels in Milwaukee
• Google Scholar: MLB Players Haunted Hotels
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Haunted Hotels
• Google News: Dodgers Haunted Pfister Hotel

Author: STAFF HERE MILWAUKEE WRITER

MILWAUKEE STAFF WRITER The MILWAUKEE STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREMilwaukee.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Milwaukee, Milwaukee County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Summerfest, Milwaukee Film Festival, and the Milwaukee Boat Show. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce and Visit Milwaukee, plus leading businesses in manufacturing and brewing that power the local economy such as Harley-Davidson and MillerCoors. As part of the broader HERE network, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Wisconsin's dynamic landscape.